Skip to main content

CDPAP 2024 Litigation Overview

The Situation Report | January 13, 2025

HCANYS Staff is aware of at least nine (9) different lawsuits relating to the Consumer Directed Personal Assistance Program (CDPAP). Six (6)of the cases were filed in state court and three (3) lawsuits were filed in federal court. This overview focuses on the six cases filed in NY state courts.

The six state court cases relate to a few different aspects of CDPAP. The first lawsuit is a case challenging the new administrative rate methodology. Four other cases focus on the selection of the single statewide fiscal intermediary (SFI) and the RFP process. The sixth case relates to the Department of Health (DOH) response to a Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) request (specifically, a FOIL request for copies of certain financial reports submitted by existing fiscal intermediaries to NYS).

According to the NYS Unified Court System (NYSUCS) case tracking database, various legal documents have been filed in each of the cases and certain actions have been taken in the various legal proceedings. Based on the NYSUCS data, an overview of the cases, parties, courts, issue, primary arguments, relief sought, and status/highlights is below.

Consumer Directed Personal Assistance Association of NYS et. al. vs. McDonald et. al.

Petitioner Type: An association of FI’s & various individual FI’s (including ILC’s)

Respondents: DOH Commissioner McDonald & NYS DOH

State Court: Albany County Supreme Court

Issue: Administrative Rate Methodology

Petitioner's Main Arguments:

- DOH adopted the rule without proper legal notice under NY law;
- The rule violates other regulations and is arbitrary/capricious;
- DOH violated duty to use sufficient data/analysis in setting rate.

Relief Sought:

- Stop implementation of the new rate methodology;
- Declaration that new rate methodology is null/void & of no effect.

Highlights:

- Lawsuit commenced on 7/22/24;
- Petitioner’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction denied on 10/9/24;
- Respondents filed a Notice of Motion to Dismiss on 11/15/24.

Save Our Consumer Directed Home Care Program vs. NYS Department of Health (DOH) et. al.

Petitioner Type: Coalition of FI’s, other CDPAP participants, & CDPAP Consumers

Respondents: NYS DOH & DOH Commissioner McDonald

State Court: Albany County Supreme Court

Issue: Statewide Fiscal Intermediary

Petitioner's Main Arguments:

- DOH violated federal HHS regulations since DOH failed to follow state and federal procurement rules;
- DOH RFP is arbitrary/capricious because it did not provide proper justification for a single SFI;
- DOH violated the separation of powers doctrine in the NYS Constitution by setting criteria not approved by the NY Legislature;
- DOH singled out certain groups violating equal protection rules.
- Various violations of US Constitution (contracts/commerce);
- DOH violated the Medicaid Act by infringing on consumer rights to freedom of choice of providers;
- DOH violated the ADA & Olmstead decision by segregating individuals with disabilities.

Relief Sought:

- Order preventing further action on the SFI RFP;
- Declaration that law requiring the SFI is unconstitutional;
- Declaration that SFI & RFP are pre-empted by Medicaid laws.

Highlights:

- Lawsuit commenced on 8/12/24;
- Oral arguments on Preliminary Injunction held on 10/11/24;
- On 12/10/24, Petitioner again requested Court to review the Motion for Preliminary Injunction.

Corning Council for Assistance and Information for the Disabled et. al. vs. McDonald et.al.

Petitioner Type: Various independent living centers (ILC’s), FI’s, and LHCSA’s

Respondents: DOH Commissioner McDonald & NYS DOH

State Court: Albany County Supreme Court

Issue: Statewide Fiscal Intermediary

Petitioner's Main Arguments:

- The NYS SFI Law violates equal protection and due process by excluding NY FIs that have statewide experience only in NY;
- The NYS SFI Law is an unlawful “bill of attainder” because it excludes NY FIs to punish them for perceived fraud in CDPAP;
- The RFP violates equal protection by treating LHCSAs differently than other FIs.
- The RFP is arbitrary/capricious since it excludes Petitioners from bidding because they provide FI services only in New York;

Relief Sought:

- Temporary Restraining Order on submission of RFP bids;
- Preliminary injunction to stop RFP process for selection of SFI;
- Permanent injunction to stop RFP process for selection of SFI;
- Declaration that law requiring the SFI is unconstitutional.

Highlights:

- Lawsuit commenced on 8/16/24;
- Petitioner’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction denied on 9/30/24;
- Petitioner filed Notice of Appeal on 10/7/24

Freedom Care LLC vs. NYS DOH, DOH Commissioner McDonald, & Public Partnerships LLC

Petitioner Type: Existing NYS Fiscal Intermediary

Respondents: NYSDOH, DOH Commissioner McDonald, & PPL

State Court: New York County Supreme Court

Issue: Statewide Fiscal Intermediary

Petitioner's Main Arguments:

- DOH RFP is arbitrary/capricious because bid process was a sham/rigged for PPL;
- Award of contract to PPL is arbitrary and capricious because PPL is not a “responsible” bidder;
- DOH actions are arbitrary/capricious because the contract was not awarded to the proposal presenting the “best value”.

Relief Sought:

- Declaration that selection of PPL as SFI violated law.
- Annulment of the SFI contract award to PPL;
- Preliminary injunction to stop the contract award.

Highlights:

- Lawsuit commenced on 11/25/24;
- On 11/27/24, Judge issued Order to Show Cause (OSC) requiring Respondents to address Petitioner’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction;
- Oral argument scheduled for 1/8; but Respondents (NYSDOH) requested a postponement since Respondent claims that Petitioner (Freedom Care) filed new additional factual allegations on 1/7/25.

Glidedowan, LLC d/b/a All-American Homecare v. NYS DOH, DOH Commissioner McDonald, & Michael Lewandowski (DOH Office of Health Insurance Programs)

Petitioner Type: Existing NYS Fiscal Intermediary

Respondents: NYSDOH, DOH Commissioner McDonald, & Michael Lewandowski (DOH Office of Health Insurance Programs)

State Court: Livingston County Supreme Court

Issue: Statewide Fiscal Intermediary (Data exchange)

Petitioner's Main Arguments:

- DOH has no legal authority to require All-American Homecare to provide consumer and personal assistant information;
- DOH has no legal authority to direct All-American Homecare to notify consumers and personal assistants (PAs) of the proposed transition to a statewide fiscal intermediary (SFI);
- DOH directives would cause All-American Homecare to violate HIPAA.

Relief Sought:

- Prohibit DOH from requiring All-American Homecare to provide consumer and PA information to third parties.
- Prohibit DOH from requiring All-American Homecare from notifying consumers and PAs of the proposed transition to a SFI.

Highlights:

- Lawsuit filed on 1/6/25;
- On 1/7/25, Judge issued Order to Show Cause (OSC) that includes a temporary restraining order (TRO). The order temporarily stops the required transfer of consumer and PA data and the required notifications to consumers and PAs of the proposed SFI transition.
- Oral argument scheduled for 1/27/25.

Empire Center for Public Policy vs. NYS Department of Health

Petitioner Type: Albany-based not-for-profit “think tank”

Respondents: NYSDOH

State Court: Albany County Supreme Court

Issue: DOH failure to provide CDPAP FI financial reports pursuant to Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) Request (the financial reports would provide information on the cost of CDPAP to the state).

Petitioner's Main Arguments: DOH constructively denied disclosure of the records.

Relief Sought:

- Declaration that DOH violated FOIL laws.
- Declaration that DOH must provide the requested records.

Highlights:

 - Lawsuit commenced on 12/10/24
- On 12/2724, the parties agreed to discontinue the legal proceeding.